Add This

Sunday, April 24, 2011

Crime & Punishment

A man gets arrested for stealing an apple. Instead of dealing with the thief directly, the judge's son gets murdered to pay for the theft of the apple that someone else ate. Does the punishment fit the crime?
Sounds bizarre.
It being the Easter season, I am thinking about the cruici-"fiction" story and shaking my head. A light goes on for me.
At this point, patriarchal Christian religions are sure to point to a scripture in the Bible to justify the insane reaction by their punishing god. "Through one man sin entered into the world and death through sin, and thus death spread to all men because they had all sinned." — Romans 5:12 New World Translation.
Oh sure, I have heard that explanation pounded into my brain since I was born, but the logic eludes me still.
So Adam ate an apple. Why the need for capital punishment? Couldn't god just say, "Adam, I know you are a newbie on the earthly scene, so I'm going to forgive you and thus teach you a great lesson in love." But, no! God insists on blood. Nothing short of a human sacrifice would appease this blood-thirsty god.
Stop and think about it. Doesn't that "original sin" story lay a heavy load of guilt on humans for all eternity, when all that was needed was one loving act of forgiveness? Seriously, what rational, reasonable person would see Jesus' death sentence as a balance of justice — simply because Adam ate an apple?
God didn't just think it; according to the Bible he enacted it. That's what the whole deal is around the Easter story. Here on in, all sons must cringe and obey the honor stuff spewed by their fathers lest some imagined shame fall upon the family name. God set the example. Where honor is at stake, a blood sacrifice must be the payment price.
Sounds dark.
Most Christian religions teach the "original sin" story. I'm sorry, I'm not buying what patriarchal religions are selling. It's time to forgive Adam and all his offspring. After all, he is just human. Time to drop the self-righteous honor stuff. Drop the punishing belief system. Lighten up, show some forgiveness and love — starting from the top down — okay boys?
Oh, and somehow, a woman got blamed for the entire scenario…? Only under patriarchal rule *sigh*.

Visit website "Phoenix of Faith" the memoir. Follow on Twitter: _Phoenixoffaith Copyright © 2011. Permission is granted to copy and re-distribute this transmission on the condition that it is distributed freely.


  1. Salvation theology in Christianity, just as you are explaining, requires tortuous logic. We have Augustine of Hippo to thank for that, as well as Original Sin and pro-life/anti-abortion thinking.

  2. Gosh Anon,
    I tried to read the link, but my eyes went crossed. Strange phenomenon...